According to
Awards-->
1st 15+ War Merit Cross (Top 2 are swapped in the pictures)
2nd 12+ Knight's Cross
3rd 9+ German Cross in Gold
4th 6+ Honor Cup
5th 3+ Iron Cross 1st Class
6th 0+ Iron Cross 2nd Class
My score after all stats and LL= 20
Herr Dobs after LL= 16
Herr Zilla= 15.75 (depending on how the AI AA was scored)
Little bit of research reveals the pictures to be more correct, which I am assuming you are going with.
.....but.....since we are in the land of confusion...
How come we don't use the oak leaves, swords, diamonds steps? War Merit is kind of on the low end of the Merit system.. Meh, no need to blow up years of tradition for a trivial video game award.