Split,
Your question is valid and after analysis my adjudication is as follows:
>> Warbird's field closing parameters only requires certain elements to be destroyed for it to credit a closing. Based on the attached files
damage to the radar is not required to close a field but is to close a radar instillation.
>> Field 1 (closed) is located in an area that is still under Allied control. The pictures attached show that the radar was damaged at F1 and we
can assume that repairs are being done by Allied personal but, based on the rules, will not be completed before the end of the series.
>> The pictures also show that the radar installation was destroyed at F89. By reference to point 2, the radar station, also in
Allied territory, while destroyed is the main focus of repairs and can be reopened but not by the next frame. Therefore, F89 will not be open
for frame two but will be for frame three. I base this ruling on the historical fact that English civilian observer stations created to
supplement the newly developed radar was equally effective in providing early warning to Bomber Command. However, Warbirds has no
ability to create a civilian observer force. The ruling to allow all (Allied and Axis) radar to reopen after a one frame hiatus has been instituted for the MVM series.
>> Unless the parsed log shows that radar is clearly destroyed, no extra points beyond the stated award for closing will be award to either side.
| Attachments: |
|
Radar destroyed.JPG [ 35.92 KiB | Viewed 2058 times ] |
|
Radar damaged not destroyed.JPG [ 96.35 KiB | Viewed 2058 times ] |
.