jabo wrote:
From ages ago the T+160 rule is hard and fast because of all the bitterness it brings up having late kills and such.
I attached to Hawk and saw no torpedoes launched until after I posted T+161. Call it a BS flag but next time if the Kamis are late launching I will ground them to avoid this situation. So now it becomes if you are not within 10 miles of the CV by T+150 all attacks must RTB. Same goes for Allied Avengers or B29s.
Personally, I think if Jabo is going to enforce the T+160 surface attack time down to the second of weapons release then he needs to erase all the action directly attributable to the late launch.
Everyone was operating in good faith with no attempt to "game" the rules and a lot of people died on both sides supporting and defending the Kamikaze attack on the CV.
My understanding was that the T+160 rule was sort of like the RTB if not engaged rule, open to some leeway on either side.
Everything the Allies were doing after T+130 was to defend the CV and everything the Japs were doing after T+130 was to support the Kamikaze attack.
So if the CV attack doesn't count then the 30 minutes prior should just be erased from the points total. Personally, I don't care if individual kills are still counted for lifetime totals or not but the Frame scoring should not reflect all the action for a Kamikaze attack that Jabo appeared to referee as valid until the moment of destruction when he declared it outside the rules.